| Peter Nelson
Vice-President and Principal Owner
Marc Nelson Oil Products
1977 Claxter Road, NE
Salem, OR 97303
Statement for the Record
U.S. Senate Finance Committee
Federal Estate Tax: Uncertainty in Planning Under the Current
Law
November 14, 2007
Chairman Baucus, Ranking Member Grassley, and members of
the Senate Finance Committee: I am honored to present testimony
on the Federal Estate Tax, better known as the “death
tax.” My story is about a company resilient enough to
be founded in the middle of the depression, but which could
be destroyed by the death tax.
Marc Nelson Oil Products is a strong family-owned business
with an Achilles heel: neither the business nor its owners
have considerable cash reserves. This otherwise innocuous
fact makes the business acutely vulnerable to the death tax.
Without cash or other liquid assets, it will be a real hardship
to pay the death tax’s heavy confiscatory rate of 55
percent. Our business, which specializes in the distribution
of oil products, is worth $6-7 million, well above the exemption
amount. My family has successfully grown the company for over
70 years, since its founding by my grandfather in 1935. We
also have operated a 240 acre Christmas tree farm for the
same period, worth roughly the same amount and with almost
as much in liquid assets.
Contrary to public opinion, businesses such as Marc Nelson
Oil Products and our farm are not awash in cash profits which
can be plundered for such events as the death tax. Our capital
is very limited and is regularly reinvested in the business.
When the death tax comes due, I will very likely be forced
to sell some of my assets in order to provide the cash needed
for paying it. In doing so, I will substantially weaken my
company’s growth potential and possibly hamper its long-term
sustainability.
In order to prevent the worst effects of the death tax, I
have spent excessive amounts of money and time with my lawyer
and CPA to implement the latest estate planning techniques.
This has resulted in a gross misallocation of productive resources.
When I should be building my business and investing in new
growth opportunities, I have instead spent hours and a small
fortune to try and make the company sustainable when my father
dies. Without the death tax, I have no doubt that Marc Nelson
Oil Products would be considerably more profitable and create
more jobs.
Even with my efforts, it is very possible that I will be
forced to sell assets in order to pay the death tax. If this
happens, it will not only hurt me, the business owner, but
also the 30 employees and their families who depend on Marc
Nelson Oil Products for a steady income. These employees should
not be punished for their decision to work for a family-owned
company.
What I find most aggravating about the death tax is that
it only punishes those who reinvest their income and grow
their business, while those who squander their earnings on
consumption are exempted from the tax. Like most Americans,
I have devoted my life to productive endeavors. However, the
tax which supposedly only falls on the “idle rich”
now threatens my very livelihood, due to the fact that I invested
my wealth in my company. If Congress really cares about addressing
the needs of hard-working family-business owners in America,
repealing the death tax should be the first priority.
Respectfully submitted,
Peter Nelson
Vice-President and COO
Marc Nelson Oil Products
|